N.Y.P.D. Pizza Colerain / Peachgrove

Located on Springdale Road in Cincinnati, N.Y.P.D. Pizza Colerain / Peachgrove is a beloved pizza and Italian restaurant that has cultivated a loyal following for its authentic, satisfying, and wonderfully crafted dishes. Specializing in classic and creative pizzas, this local gem delivers not only in flavor but also in friendly, dependable service—whether you dine in or order meal delivery.

Step into N.Y.P.D. Pizza and you are greeted by the inviting aroma of freshly baked dough mingling with savory Italian herbs, pepperoni, and melting cheese. Their menu showcases a variety of crowd-pleasers, but some standouts truly deserve special mention. The Station House 9-inch pizza masterfully balances the hearty flavors of pepperoni, Italian sausage, fresh mushrooms, onions, and green peppers—a perfect harmony of veggies and meats. For those who crave robust, meaty indulgence, the Meatbuster 9-inch loaded with pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, and ground beef is a savory feast designed to satisfy even the most ravenous appetites. Vegetable lovers will be enchanted by the Garden Lovers 9-inch, where fresh mushrooms, diced tomatoes, onions, green olives, and green peppers create a vibrant medley bursting with freshness.

Beyond their signature pies, N.Y.P.D. Pizza also tempts with exceptional sides and specialties such as their much-praised wings, known for their perfect balance of crispiness and bold, flavorful seasoning. The Fire Bites are another highlight—available for a limited time—and add a kick that leaves a lasting impression. Not to be missed on the menu is the unique Pickle Pizza Eater, a playful and inventive creation that showcases the restaurant's fun, creative approach to classic pizza.

Customers consistently rave about the quality and care found in every order. Nicole Hacker shares that their pretzels rival, if not surpass, the famed Auntie Anne’s, a testament to N.Y.P.D.’s commitment to making every bite memorable. Loyal patron Drone Derek has chosen this spot for over a decade and attests to their exceptional consistency and excellent customer service, even recalling how the management swiftly resolved a rare mix-up with grace and professionalism. Ralph McDaniel Jr emphasizes the undeniable superiority in taste and value over larger chain stores, highlighting that N.Y.P.D. captures the “way a pizza is supposed to taste.”

The dining atmosphere at N.Y.P.D. Pizza strikes the perfect balance between casual comfort and warm neighborhood charm. Whether you’re picking up your order or dining with family and friends, you sense the passion and authenticity behind every dish. Quick, fresh, and thoughtfully prepared pizzas arrive ready to delight, just as Kati Payne experienced with her prompt and fully loaded orders.

Perhaps the most inspiring testimonial comes from Day Crutcher, who lauds N.Y.P.D. Pizza’s community spirit and willingness to go above and beyond by supporting local events like the Fallen Bikers and Ryders Foundation Toy Fundraiser. Here, food is more than just nourishment—it’s a vehicle for connection, service, and joy.

For those seeking a genuine Italian-American culinary experience that consistently delivers flavor, value, and heartfelt service, N.Y.P.D. Pizza Colerain / Peachgrove stands out as a true Cincinnati treasure. The moment you taste their expertly crafted pizzas, you understand why so many keep coming back—because here, pizza is an art, a comfort, and a celebration all rolled into one.